Red Dead Redemption
While not all the games on this list are Xbox exclusives, every game is at least more performant or better-looking on Xbox than PlayStation, provided you’re playing on a One X.
Red Dead Redemption Cuphead
Studio MDHR’s Cuphead is as beautiful as it is challenging — and it’s very beautiful. Half bullet-hell shooter, half platformer, half classic boss rush… wait that’s too many halves. Either way, Cuphead pulled in basically everyone with its charming, hand-drawn visuals that look like they’re straight out of the 1930s. It then kept them around with tough-as-nails gameplay which somehow never feels unfair. It has some of the most memorable boss fights you’re ever likely to have — Cala Maria is our favorite — but what will stay with you the most is that feeling of finally beating the one you get stuck on, 273 deaths later. AS
Red Dead Redemption Forza Horizon 4
The Forza Horizon games have always second fiddle to the main series, but in Forza Horizon 4, Playground Games has made our favorite Forza game ever. Horizon 4 takes the arcadey gameplay and open world of the series to Great Britain, exploring some of England, Scotland and Wales’ most beautiful landmarks. All the cars you’d expect are here, but perhaps the most interesting addition is the seasons. You see, the game’s enormous map totally transforms with the time year, and with it, so does the way the cars handle. There is a whole lot of game here, and all of it is very fun. AS
Red Dead Redemption Gears of War 4
This is the generation when every video-game protagonist became a dad, and in Gears of War 4, you literally play as the series lead’s son. Gears of War 4 doesn’t mess with a winning formula — it feels like a warm hug of a video game. Or at least, as much of a warm hug a game in which you kill thousands of Locust scum can be. There are some new weapons — most notably a gun that fires circular saw blades at enemies — and a pretty good story, but this is the Gears you remember, turned up to 11. AS
Red Dead Redemption Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice isn’t just another Dark Souls game. FromSoftware’s samurai adventure is a departure from that well-established formula, replacing slow, weighty combat and gothic despair for stealth, grappling hooks and swift swordplay. Oh, and while it’s still a difficult game, it’s a lot more accessible than Souls games — you can even pause it! The result of all these changes is something that’s still instantly recognizable as a FromSoftware title, but it’s its own thing, and it’s very good. AS
Red Dead Redemption Nier: Automata
It took more than a while to get here, but Nier: Automata finally arrived on Xbox One in the summer of 2018. And boy, was it worth the almost-18-month wait. Nier takes the razor-sharp combat of a Platinum Games title and puts it in a world crafted by everyone’s favorite weirdo, Yoko Taro. Don’t worry, you can mostly just run, gun and slash your way through the game, but as you finish, and finish and finish this one, you’ll find yourself pulled into a truly special narrative, one that’s never been done before and will probably never be done again. Unmissable. AS
Red Dead Redemption Ori and the Blind Forest
Arriving at a time when “Gears Halo Forza” seemed to be the beginning, middle and end of Microsoft’s publishing plans, Ori and the Blind Forest was a triumph. It’s a confident mash of the pixel-perfect platforming popularized by Super Meat Boy, and the rich, unfolding worlds of Metroidvania games. You’ll die hundreds of times exploring the titular forest, unlocking skills that allow you to reach new areas. It looks and sounds great — like, Disney great — and its story, while fairly secondary to the experience, is interesting. Ori might not do much to push the boundaries of its genres, but everything it does, it does so right. AS
Red Dead Redemption Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the kind of game no one but Rockstar, the team behind the GTA series, could make. Only when a studio is this successful can it pour millions of dollars and man-hours into a game. Rockstar’s simulation of a crumbling frontier world is enthralling and serves as a perfect backdrop to an uncharacteristically measured story. While the studio’s gameplay may not have moved massively forward, the writing and characters of RDR2 will stay with you. AS
Take the weird Twin Peaks narrative of Alan Wake, smash it together with Quantum Break‘s frenetic powers and gunplay, and you’ve got Control. Playing as a woman searching for her missing brother, you quickly learn there’s a thin line between reality and the fantastical. It’s catnip for anyone who grew up loving The X-Files and the supernatural. It’s also a prime example of a studio working at their creative heights, both refining and evolving the open-world formula that’s dominated games for the past decade. DH
Red Dead Redemption The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
It might be the best open-world RPG out there. Despite now being several years old, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a dense action game that acknowledges the maturity of the player with multiple — occasionally harrowing — storylines, choices that have consequences and almost too much game to wrestle with. It’s not perfect: the combat system is rough, frustrating death comes in the form of falling from just a few feet and there’s a lot of quest filler alongside many incredibly well thought out distractions. The scope and ambition on display will have you hooked, and once you’re done, there are some excellent expansions to check out. MS
Contributors: Devindra Hardawar (DH), Mat Smith (MS), Aaron Souppouris (AS).
September 2019: ‘Gears of War 4’ replaced by ‘Gears 5’
December 2019: ‘Control’ supplants ‘Resident Evil 7’
Prices accurate on date of publish.
All products recommended by Engadget are selected by our editorial team, independent of our parent company. Some of our stories include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.